Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Johnny Got His Gun 4

In these chapters, Joe reveals his thoughts about death. He tells us what he thinks people should fight for, and what is actually worth fighting for. Joe thinks that nothing is worth fighting for if in the end you end up losing your life. Many people believe that sacrificing their life to fight for something like democracy, liberty, or independence does not mean anything. Those are just word, and no one truly understands the meaning of them. When someone dies, people gather around and talk about how they did not die in vain, but that is not true according to Joe. Joe says that how can we say what the dead feel. If none of us have actually been dead, how do we know that they did not die in vain. In actuality when a person is about to die, they are not thinking about what they have just done to help their country, instead they are thinking about how they wish they were going to live. Fighting for something, and then dying for that cause is essentially pointless because you never actually get to experience the thing that you were fighting for. However, Joe does believe that a person's life is worth fighting for. One should not have to fight for the freedom of liberty of other people. They should get to experience as well. Therefore, the only think that is worth fighting for is one's own life.

2 comments:

Ashley said...

This is a very well developed and conceptual blog sonia! I like how you have tied up all the concepts into one in the final statement about having the only thing worth preserving (fighting for) would be yourself.
It is ironic that he speaks this way in my opinion because here he is, wanting to die, when he is somewhat living through what he fought for. However his fighting caused him to be in a worse state than to die..so maybe it is not so ironic.

Abby V. said...

I agree with you in that Joe says how can you know what you are fighting for until you are dying. He has a problem with this because he knows that he is extremely close to death, therefore he knows what he was fighting for, just his own life. he was not fighting for liberty or democracy which is what people told the soldiers to fight for, he is fighting for essentially nothing, except to keep himself alive. Good job!